With more than 16 years of real estate experience, Nathan is known for his strategic marketing expertise, strong negotiation skills and genuine connection to the Dingley Village and Bayside communities. Backed by a diverse professional background and deep life experience, Nathan brings energy, insight and a highly personalised approach to delivering exceptional outcomes for his clients.

What do your clients commonly say you do differently?

Clients often say they value the level of care, strategy, and attention to detail I bring to every campaign. I’m highly focused on presentation and identifying simple but impactful improvements that elevate a property without unnecessary overspending. Every campaign is tailored to the right target market, backed by strategic marketing, strong negotiation skills, and a genuine commitment to achieving premium results.

How has your career led you to the role you’re in today?

My career journey has been anything but conventional. Before real estate, I worked in international finance, as a Floor Manager on Neighbours, and helped establish the Gloria Jean’s coffee brand in Australia. Each role taught me something different about people, business, adaptability, and communication. For the past 17 years, I’ve channelled all of that experience into real estate, combining strategic thinking, strong negotiation, and genuine care to deliver exceptional outcomes for clients.

What’s something only locals know about this area?

Dingley Village is one of those rare suburbs where people move in and never want to leave. There’s a genuine sense of community here that locals truly value. From the cafés and sporting clubs to the Farmers Market and quiet family-friendly streets, it’s a suburb built on connection and lifestyle.

Why Buxton?

Buxton aligns perfectly with the way I approach real estate — premium, strategic, and collaborative. The strength of the network, shared buyer database, and team culture allows us to deliver exceptional exposure and stronger results for our clients.

Reviews

4.95

Nathan has a 4.95 star rating, according to realestate.com.au.

Last updated: June 2026

We have had a great experience working with Nathan + Melissa. My partner and I first enquired on an Auction campaign 4 days before the Auction. Nathan was very quick to turn around all the documentation requested, organise our inspection, and building/pest inspection before the Auction deadline. He was very honest and transparent which made us feel comfortable to not just pursue the Auction, but purchase the property. Would have no hesitation working with Nathan again.

Lockey A

Nathan provided excellent guidance and advice regarding the sale of our property. He tempered our expectations and achieved a satisfactory price within a very reasonable time.

Mike N

From our initial meeting with Nathan and Melissa, we knew we had selected the right agents to sell our family home of 50 years. Nathan and Melissa were interested in our story and connection with our home. Nathans knowledge of the real estate business was outstanding, as he explained all aspects, positive and negative of our journey to selling our home. We would highly recommend Nathan and Melissa to anyone considering selling their home. We were very pleased with the sale result.

Brendan H

Nathan is amazing at what he does, absolute professional and extremely good at the business side of real estate. Highly recommend Nathan personally and professionally

Abraham D

We have known Nathan for many years and when it came to sell our investment property, he was the one to turn too. Nathan was exceptional. I was impressed with his promptness, professionalism, attention to detail, advice, level of knowledge and the way he did the video presentation. He was great to deal with and made the experience stress free. I highly recommend him to others.

Andrew O

Nathan was truly exceptional. I was impressed with his level of knowledge and the way he did the video presentation…In addition, his promptness, professionalism and good energy made our selling process simple.

Ashanthi T

Nathan was absolutely brilliant in selling our property, amazing negotiating skills and a true professional in real estate, would not hesitate to use nathan and Buxton again as there is a reason they are rated so highly.

George R

Nathan, was professional and helpful during the whole process. His suggestions help guide me to make the decisions that needed to be made.

Susanne B

After the stressful transition from selling the family home to buying the new family home, it was the likes of Nathan & the rest of the team at Buxton Dingley Village that really made the experience far easier & I thought I would never say it but pleasurable! If it came time to sell again we would not go anywhere else.

Glen B

We recently sold our house in Dingley with Buxton Real Estate, and we couldn't be more pleased with the experience. Despite being interstate, we felt completely at ease knowing our property was in capable hands. Nathan and the team organised efficient tradespeople, a fantastic furniture stylist, and skilled gardeners who prepared our property beautifully. They kept us well-informed throughout the entire campaign, making the process hassle-free. We highly recommend Nathan at Buxton Real Estate!

Robyn B

Dingley Village

Nathan is thorough and across the market in Dingley. He was able to articulate to our family, how the sale process would work and their strategy for gaining the best price for us.

Garry S

Dingley Village

Nathan is a work of art! The way he helped me find my dream home, ticked all the boxes! Fantastic agent with extensive knowledge of the area. Loved working with Nathan and his team.

Maria M

Dingley Village

Nathan is so lovely to work with and is definitely an expert in the Dingley area. He has been patient and helpful, accommodating and flexible to support us buyers. We really appreciate his professional knowledge and advice. Thanks Nathan for making this purchase experience as positive as possible.

Silvia W

Dingley Village

We’ve worked with Nathan, Mel and the Buxton Team on buying our home and selling two properties, and they’ve been amazing every time! Most recently, they helped us sell our home and totally blew our expectations out of the water. Their energy, expertise, and genuine care made the whole process smooth and we always felt in the loop, informed, and supported every step of the way. We’re so grateful to have had them on our team and can’t recommend them enough. Huge thanks for everything!

Stephanie K

Dingley Village

We engaged Nathan at Buxton Dingley for the sale of our property. His experience and expertise with realty in Dingley, gave us the confidence that he would get us the best outcome possible. The auction exceeded our expectations beyond words. We highly recommend him to any vendor. Thank you so much to Nathan, Melissa, Katie and the team at Buxton Dingley

Dimi M

Dingley Village

Find our dream home and Nathan was great during all the process. Great team!

Frederic s

Dingley Village

We couldn't be happier with our experience! Nathan and the team not only secured a successful deal for us, but also executed a brilliant marketing plan that performed above our expectations throughout the sales campaign. Their constant, clear communication made the whole process smooth and stress-free. A true professional!

Steven C

Dingley Village

We had a great experience with Nathan and the team. Great advise and excellent results!

Fraser T

Dingley Village

Nathan and team were absolute professionals. His communication throughout the process was fantastic and left us with no questions in such a significant transaction. He's knowledge of the Dingley and surrounding area market was exceptional, and helped us have confidence in our strategy. All in all, Nathan was personable, knowledgeable, professional and he helped us exceed our reserve. Thank you Nathan and team!

Roberto G

Dingley Village

A huge thank you to Nathan, Katie and team for helping us sell our little family home. From the very beginning, their communication was outstanding — always keeping us informed and answering every question with patience and care. Their persistence and dedication ensured we achieved a fantastic price, and the whole process felt smooth and well-managed. We’re so grateful for their hard work and highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell.

Aisling M

Dingley Village

We recently sold our house with Buxton, and it was an absolute delight! Nathan, Michal, and their team were nothing short of fantastic. They were by our side every step of the way, making the whole process a breeze. We can’t recommend them enough!

Sippy A

Dingley Village

Thank you Nathan and everyone at Buxton for all the help, support and guidance over the last little while. Buying and selling is not for the faint of heart but the team was absolutely amazing through both. We truly wouldn't have wanted to do it without them all! Thank you for wonderful result and thank you for taking our endless calls. We'll miss hanging out every weekend at open homes and late night text messages lol. They're a great bunch of people who are committed to doing the very best!

Melissa M

Clayton South

Nathan and his team were our first choice and didn’t disappoint with professionalism, honesty and sensitivity during our emotional sale of our childhood home. Auction day was a breeze and provided us with the outcome we were told to expect, couldn’t be happier in recommending Buxton Real Estate.

Kim C

Dingley Village

Nathan, Mel and the team were very supportive through the process to get us the best final result, would highly recommend for those looking to sell their property.

Connor D

Mordialloc

Nathan and his team at Buxton were recommended to us by a trusted associate active in the property market. They recently helped us achieve an excellent result with the sale of our property in Chelsea Heights. The sales plan was sound, communication was clear and consistent, and while results can never be guaranteed, in our case the outcome exceeded expectations. We’re very happy with the process and result, and hope others experience the same success with this team.

Craig M

Chelsea Heights

Nathan and his team team were outstanding to work with throughout the purchase of our first home. Their integrity, honesty and clear communication far exceeded any other agents we dealt with during our search. Positive, friendly and supportive from start to finish — exactly the kind of agent you want on your side, whether buying or selling.

Katie B

Clayton South

Engaged Nathan and his team to sell my home. The marketing and internet presence was put together brilliantly and was outstanding against other properties in the area. Nathan, Melissa and Katie were 100% professional and their interaction with both me and prospective purchasers was fantastic. Got the end result that I wanted with minimal fuss and certainly little stress. Highly recommend Nathan and his team to anyone looking to sell their home.

Greg M

Bangholme

The agent did a fantastic job of selling our property we were stressed that we would have no interested parties as informed by the agent but ended up being a fantastic outcome for us and the new purchasers who are fantastic!

Mark B

Dingley Village

Selling my mum’s unit after 40 years was a significant and emotional milestone for our family, and Nathan Arrowsmith — together with Melissa and Katie — made the entire process smooth, supportive and unexpectedly positive. From the outset, Nathan told us the unit had a real “vibe,” and he backed that confidence with genuine professionalism, honesty and charisma. Melissa and Katie were equally fantastic — organised, warm, and always ready to help with any question or detail, big or small.

Michelle R

Highett

Nathan and Melissa were a great team to deal with. They were both friendly, helpful and professional. Their experience of the local market was so beneficial in helping us attain our goal. We would have no hesitation in recommending them to prospective clients.

Leigh and Heather P

Dingley Village

Nathan, Katie and Mel were wonderful to deal with when selling my Dad's home. They were professional, honest, patient and wonderful with communicating, especially when they were faced with needing to communicate to all family members. They gave useful advice along the way and had a great network of people behind the scene. I would highly recommend Nathan and team to any potential buyer or seller.

Chrissy K

Aspendale

Nathan Arrowsmith was our real estate agent. His market knowledge is extensive and underpinned by expert analysis of data and local trends. We felt well informed and well prepared throughout the sale process as a result of having Nathan’s expertise. He is caring and kind and a great communicator and nothing is too much trouble. He listens to what you want to achieve and designs a campaign to get you the best possible results. We were so impressed with Nathan’s professionalism.

Robyn W

Dingley Village

I recently purchased a new home through Nathan and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. Nathan brings energy and enthusiasm to every interaction and his friendly disposition ensured I wasn’t made to feel a burden. What really stood out was his honesty and transparency, I always felt well informed and confident that I was getting clear, genuine advice. He was also truly thrilled for me when everything came together, which made the experience even more special and personal.

Esther M

Carrum

Nathan was amazing! Very knowledgeable of the local area and up with whats going on in the market. He was genuine and very understanding of our families situation and helped us navigate that with sensitivity and without any pressure. Very happy with the outcome!

Leah C

Dingley Village

Nathan is an amazing Real Estate Agent in Dingley Village. Very professional, excellent communicator and helpful. We purchased our new family home through Nathan and the team and the way he treated the home, buyers and the vendors were with utmost care and respect. All of our questions were answered promptly to make critical final decisions and did not try to play any "real estate" games. Definitely genuine, friendly and knowledgeable agent in the area ♥️ Thankyou once again for our purchase!

Phi D

Dingley Village

Nathan and Melissa did an amazing job selling our first home last weekend and helped us achieve an incredible result! From start to finish they were professional and completely on top of every detail while having some fun along the way! They made the stressful process feel smooth and we always felt confident that we were in good hands. We’re so grateful for their work and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Nathan and Melissa to anyone looking to sell their home 👌👌

Jessica A

Cheltenham

We couldn’t speak more highly of the Buxton Dingley Village + Keysborough team. We’ve secured our forever family home and are absolutely thrilled. Buying at auction wasn’t our first choice, but this home was perfect. Nathan is an exceptional, genuine auctioneer with a clear passion for the area. Nathan, Melissa, and Katie were responsive, transparent, and supportive throughout. We’re incredibly grateful and highly recommend the team.

Belinda K

Dingley Village

Found out as the agent for my next door property.Spoke to Nathan and felt that he has the experience and expertise to sell our life style properties.So please with the outcome of the sale price Nathan has been understanding and courteous in every step of the way Great full for Nathan and his colleagues in the sale of the property and a flashing price

Dhanalakshmy S

Bangholme

Consistent with the high standards of the entire team at Buxton Dingley Village, Nathan Arrowsmith is a highly experienced real estate agent with a no‑fuss, straight forward approach. He is efficient, well‑organised, and guides you through the selling process in a way that is easy to understand and follow. Nathan works at your pace, ensuring you feel comfortable and supported, while also providing the key ingredients needed to create a successful marketing campaign.

Adam W

Nathan was a fantastic. As first-time buyers, the process felt overwhelming at times, but Nathan guided us every step of the way with patience, honesty and clear communication. He consistently kept us informed, promptly answered our questions, and made sure we understood what was happening at each stage of the process.

Susan T

Dingley Village

Frequently Asked

Here to help

Your Buxton agent will cover the details - here’s a clear view of what an appraisal involves.

We approach appraisals as a practical conversations, grounded in real data, local insight and what matters most to you.

Speak to us

Your Buxton agent visits your property, considers its features, location, and market conditions, and combines that with recent sales data to give you a clear, realistic view of its value.

We analyse comparable properties, current market trends, and your home’s unique qualities. From there, we provide a considered range that reflects what buyers are likely to pay.

Not at all. An appraisal is simply insight - a way to understand your home’s value and your options before making any decisions.

Typically, we recommend an in-person appraisal so we can assess your property fully. In some cases, a virtual appraisal can provide a helpful initial guide.

Agents weigh factors differently - recent sales, market conditions, and property features. At Buxton, we combine local insight, data, and experience to provide a balanced, realistic appraisal you can trust.

Get in touch

Reach out to Nathan for property advice and local support.

My Listings

Loading listings
Loading listings

Viewing8 of 25 team members