Paul brings a career-long dedication to customer service and more than a decade of real estate leadership to every campaign. Known for honesty, punctual communication and strong auction expertise, he builds lasting relationships through trust and care. His focus is on guiding clients clearly while adding real value to their result.

What’s your personal connection to the neighbourhood?

I previously lived in Highett for over 10 years and still feel deeply connected to Kingston and Bayside. Whether I’m at local parks with my kids and dog Charlie, training nearby or visiting cafés and restaurants, I’m always bumping into familiar faces. It’s a community I genuinely live and breathe.

What do your clients commonly say you do differently?

Clients often tell me I’m not like other agents, which I take as a compliment. I’ve always worked in service-led industries, so my focus is on doing the right thing, being open and honest, and communicating clearly and punctually. I want every client to feel supported, informed and respected throughout the process.

Take us through your most meaningful client story.

One of my most meaningful sales involved supporting a couple through an incredibly difficult cancer battle. My role was to achieve the best possible result while also offering genuine care during a heartbreaking time. I donated part of my commission to their chosen charity, and it reinforced that this work is always about people, not just property.

Why Buxton?

Buxton feels like the perfect fit because it’s a dynamic brand with great people and a strong multi-office network. The collaboration across the business creates real strength for our clients. I value being part of a team that combines professionalism, support and shared ambition.

Reviews

4.95

Paul has a 4.95 star rating, according to realestate.com.au.

Last updated: July 2026

He is not only a good auctioneer but also a good person. Really appreciate his help to me. It's a very pleasure process working with Paul.

Andy L

We used Paul and his team to sell a property in Highett. We were faced with some tricky market conditions outside of our control during the campaign. Paul and his team were always clear on there approach, offered support / advice when required, but most importantly had great communication throughout from start to finish. This ended up with us selling a property above our expectations. I’ve sold many properties over the years and this has been as close to seamless as they come. Highly recommend

Robert F

Paul was always friendly and very professional. His manner engendered confidence. His communication was excellent throughout the purchase, promptly addressing any questions we had prior to the auction and during the settlement period. His market knowledge was excellent, which he used very effectively to provide us with comparable properties to consider.

Mingwei S

He has professional skills and knowledge, and communicates and responds promptly. I am very satisfied with his work.

Ying L

Paul worked very fast to secure us the home we loved in a matter of days! We couldn't thank him enough!

Danielle C

Paul made selling the home my father built in the 50’s as positive as it could have been for my mother. He was respectful, honest and good humoured at all times. Paul and his team managed the campaign and sale without unnecessary stress on Mum and even secured her ‘ideal’ purchaser. We have nothing but praise for the work of Paul.

Claire T

I highly recommend Paul Sibley from Buxton Hampton East who recently helped me purchase my home. From start to finish, Paul was professional, knowledgeable, and dedicated to ensuring a successful purchase. Paul has always been available to answer my questions and kept me informed through the purchase process. Overall, I’m very happy with Paul’s expertise and communication skills. Thanks Paul for making the purchasing process straightforward and easy to navigate.

Sharon K

Paul was very courteous and knowledgeable about the property. Was keen to understand our situation and how would the property fit our needs and went the extra mile to make recommendations about stuff that we may want to consider. Happy that we finalised the property with Paul's help!

Gautam M

Paul was fantastic from pre-engagement discussion right the way through a long campaign. Great communication, engaging with potential buyers, and knowing when to push or pull back. And a great result (set suburb record) at the end in a tough market. Highly recommended for anyone in his area.

Dante Z

Paul has an excellent knowledge of the local market, is very responsive and a thorough professional

Jacqui F

Paul worked tirelessly to get a good price for our unit. He was always a delight to work with, super friendly and down to earth. We would recommend Paul and Buxton to anyone wanting to sell their property.

Caroline D

We appreciated Paul's motivation to make both parties happy during negotiations. He was transparent, patient, genuine and just really great to deal with. Because this was our first time buying a house, he was particularly patient - we really rated the experience working with him. When we put up the SOLD sticker, a neighbour introduced herself. Paul had sold them their house years prior, and he remembered her name and her family. It really feels like he knows the community.

Stef H

Paul was great. Super quick to respond at anytime of day, very helpful with all of our questions and a great guy. Thanks for helping us to secure our dream home!

Jessica L

Paul is highly professional, very friendly, and supportive. I had a very good experience working with him as a buyer.

Mohsen G

Paul and Natalie were absolutely fantastic with the sale of our property. They were both so helpful with suggestions for what we could do to the house to make it obtain its best price. From styling suggestions to garden suggestions. They were both absolutely brilliant and we appreciated their help enormously. They were both so professional and on the ball all the time. They kept us up to date constantly. We appreciated their advice and guidance hence they will sell our next house.

Colleen B

Was a pleasure working with Paul & Nat. Honest, genuine and easy going what more can u ask for. Thank you Buxton

steve k

Paul and his team are fantastic. Paul was a fantastic guide on the journey to selling my property and provided timely updates and info. He's sharp, friendly, and I felt that my best interests were always his priority. Ultimately he secured a dream price for my property whilst treating buyers with respect and I couldn't be more grateful. Top bloke!

Tobias T

Paul brought a depth of experience of the local market and strong negotiation skills that helped deliver an outcome at auction that we were very pleased with. Throughout the entire experience of selling we felt well supported by Paul and he really instilled trust in us. He brings an honest and calm perspective which we really appreciated and witnessed him going the extra mile for us. I would highly recommend Paul.

Joanna K

Could not be happier with Paul. He was there for us every step of the way with constant communication, market intel and most importantly an open, honest and genuine approach I have not seen with many agents. Could not recommend Paul highly enjoyable to anyone looking to sell.

Luke B

Paul was a great host at each property inspection and gave us a good run down of the market. He was well informed about the neighbourhood and took time to understand our family situation. Paul was also a great auctioneer and made sure all the bidders had a level paying field at auction.

Vikrant S

We have bought and sold through Paul before so of course we were going to engage his expertise to sell our primary residence. As usual, Paul did not let us down. He was ever attentive to our needs and queries, provided thorough and honest feedback before and during the campaign, and secured us a timely and successful sale. He allowed us to be flexible and make our own decisions without being intrusive or pushy. Above all, Paul is a great guy and comes highly recommended.

John D

Paul is knowledgable, genuine and a trusted adviser - it has been a pleasure working with Paul, Natalie and the Buxton Hampton East team. If you're looking for a no B.S approach reach out to Paul!

Mac K

We recently sold our Cheltenham home with Paul Sibley from Buxton. Paul was outstanding throughout the campaign — highly engaged, present at every open, and great at building rapport with buyers. The process ran smoothly, and Paul’s auction delivery helped us achieve a fantastic result above reserve. We chose Buxton for their network and the professional, personable approach shown by both Paul and Bessie Upchurch. Highly recommend.

Yumi W

We recently purchased a property through Paul Sibley and Bessi Upchurch at Buxton and had a fantastic experience from start to finish. They were professional, approachable, and always available to answer our questions promptly. As first home buyers they made the process feel smooth and stress-free thanks to their clear communication and genuine support.

Michael W

Paul and Natalie were professional, friendly and great communicators regarding the property we purchased.

Jazz G

Paul was very transparent about the negotiations, very responsive and arranged the sale process within two hours. It was the best buying process we have experienced since we have been looking to buy over the last 8 months.

Darby B

Paul recently helped us buy our first home. He was friendly, knowledgeable and responsive and went out of his way to make the process as easy as possible for us. Highly recommend Paul and his team.

Lienke U

Paul had his finger on the pulse of the local market which proved invaluable to us!

Gillian T

We had a great experience with Paul. He went above and beyond to help with the purchase of our property including private viewings and facilitating a short settlement.

Virginia B

Paul and Natalie's advice and help was invaluable. There knowledge of the market and my location helped me achieve a great result.

Tom W

We engaged Paul Sibley and Natalie Falvo to sell our property, and the experience was exceptional from start to finish. Paul and Natalie provided clear advice throughout the campaign and communicated promptly and professionally with all parties. Paul conducted himself with honesty and genuine trustworthiness throughout the process. Thanks to his guidance, we achieved a great result. I would not hesitate to recommend Paul to anyone looking for a reliable and highly professional agent.

Marcus S

Paul was an excellent agent who helped us successfully sell our house off-market. He was extremely accommodating of our needs throughout the entire process and used his strong negotiation skills to secure a great deal for us. We had an overall amazing experience working with Paul. He genuinely made us feel like he was on our side, always advocating for our best interests and guiding us with confidence and transparency.

Poorva M

From the inception meeting to the final sale, Paul was nothing but a pleasure to deal with, making our first time selling a swift and fun process for us. An excellent communicator with strong local knowledge, once we made the last-minute decision to sell later in the season, Paul was instrumental in helping us sell off-market with minimal fuss.

Diarmid H

I reached out to Paul Sibley when the family needed assistance selling our family home. Paul Sibley & Natalie from Buxton provided my family with exceptional service from the start to finish and I must say the best real estate agent with professionalism, market knowledge in the area, honest and accurate advice.. He was fantastic through the entire selling process with constant communication and I would highly recommend Paul Sibley to anyone wanting to sell.Thank you for all your hard work..👏

Helena D

Working with Paul and Nat was an absolute pleasure from the start. They went above and beyond our expectations in selling our home. Their combined knowledge of the local area, professional staging advice, and proactive communication made a stressful process feel effortless. They listened to our needs and were honest with their feedback. If you want a dedicated, honest, and high-achieving team, look no further than Paul and Nat!

Cathryn T

Paul and Natalie were great, easy to deal with and kept me updated throughout the process.

Paul B

Paul Sibley is an exceptional real estate agent with true compassion for both the seller and buyer, and understanding the emotions involved. We chose Paul and Nat for their professional comprehensive knowledge of the local market, plus their very positive reputation. I would recommend Paul to everyone in need of real estate expertise and focus on the interests of the seller / buyer.

Maree O

Paul was on the ball regarding price. He was both attentive and responsive to my questions. I felt that the strength of his campaign was that I felt I had a whole team acting for me. Would confidently recommend him and his company for sales/ purchases in this area.

Terry S

Happy with my all dealings with Paul.

Jenny H

Paul is great on helping me purchasing my investment property. He has been fantastic on responding my emails and queries. He is easy and enjoyable to engage with!

Mengyan G

Pleasant experience, always keep up to date of weekly activity.Satisfactory outcome given trying market.

Billie W

Since buying our house 10 years ago from Paul, he was always top of mind when it came to sell it this year. From our initial meeting to discuss our options, to putting it on the market, Paul has been amazing to deal with, responsive, supportive, down to earth and available. He built rapport with us, our family (including our dog) and most importantly the potential buyers... And we were over the moon with the result and service that he and Buxton Hampton East achieved for us. Thanks Paul!

Nat T

Frequently Asked

Here to help

Your Buxton agent will cover the details - here’s a clear view of what an appraisal involves.

We approach appraisals as a practical conversations, grounded in real data, local insight and what matters most to you.

Speak to us

Your Buxton agent visits your property, considers its features, location, and market conditions, and combines that with recent sales data to give you a clear, realistic view of its value.

We analyse comparable properties, current market trends, and your home’s unique qualities. From there, we provide a considered range that reflects what buyers are likely to pay.

Not at all. An appraisal is simply insight - a way to understand your home’s value and your options before making any decisions.

Typically, we recommend an in-person appraisal so we can assess your property fully. In some cases, a virtual appraisal can provide a helpful initial guide.

Agents weigh factors differently - recent sales, market conditions, and property features. At Buxton, we combine local insight, data, and experience to provide a balanced, realistic appraisal you can trust.

Get in touch

Reach out to Paul for property advice and local support.

My Listings

Loading listings
Loading listings

Viewing8 of 19 team members